We consider the approximation properties of quadrilateral finite element spaces of vector fields defined by the Piola transform, extending results previously obtained for scalar approximation. The finite element spaces are constructed starting with a given finite dimensional space of vector fields on a square reference element, which is then transformed to a space of vector fields on each convex quadrilateral element via the Piola transform associated to a bilinear isomorphism of the square onto the element. For affine isomorphisms, a necessary and sufficient condition for approximation of order r + 1 in L2 is that each component of the given space of functions on the reference element contain all polynomial functions of total degree at most r. In the case of bilinear isomorphisms, the situation is more complicated and we give a precise characterization of what is needed for optimal order L2 -approximation of the function and of its divergence. As applications, we demonstrate degradation of the convergence order on quadrilateral meshes as compared to rectangular meshes for some standard finite element approximations of H(div). We also derive new estimates for approximation by quadrilateral Raviart--Thomas elements (requiring less regularity) and propose a new quadrilateral finite element space which provides optimal order approximation in H(div). Finally, we demonstrate the theory with numerical computations of mixed and least squares finite element approximations of the solution of Poisson's equation.

MSC codes

  1. 65N30
  2. 41A10
  3. 41A25
  4. 41A27
  5. 41A63


  1. quadrilateral
  2. finite element
  3. approximation
  4. mixed finite element

Get full access to this article

View all available purchase options and get full access to this article.


Douglas Arnold, Daniele Boffi, Richard Falk, Approximation by quadrilateral finite elements, Math. Comp., 71 (2002), 909–922
Susanne Brenner, L. Scott, The mathematical theory of finite element methods, Texts in Applied Mathematics, Vol. 15, Springer‐Verlag, 2002xvi+361
F. Brezzi, On the existence, uniqueness and approximation of saddle‐point problems arising from Lagrangian multipliers, Rev. Française Automat. Informat. Recherche Opérationnelle Sér. Rouge, 8 (1974), 129–151
Franco Brezzi, Michel Fortin, Mixed and hybrid finite element methods, Springer Series in Computational Mathematics, Vol. 15, Springer‐Verlag, 1991x+350
Jim Douglas, Jr., Jean Roberts, Global estimates for mixed methods for second order elliptic equations, Math. Comp., 44 (1985), 39–52
R. Falk, J. Osborn, Error estimates for mixed methods, RAIRO Anal. Numér., 14 (1980), 249–277
V. Girault and P.‐A. Raviart, Finite Element Methods for Navier–Stokes Equations, Springer‐Verlag, Berlin, 1986.
Yu. Kuznetsov, S. Repin, New mixed finite element method on polygonal and polyhedral meshes, Russian J. Numer. Anal. Math. Modelling, 18 (2003), 261–278
R. Naff, T. Russell, J. Wilson, Shape functions for velocity interpolation in general hexahedral cells, Comput. Geosci., 6 (2002), 285–314, Locally conservative numerical methods for flow in porous media
A. Pehlivanov, G. Carey, R. Lazarov, Least‐squares mixed finite elements for second‐order elliptic problems, SIAM J. Numer. Anal., 31 (1994), 1368–1377
J. Shen, Mixed Finite Element Methods on Distorted Rectangular Grids, Technical report, Institute for Scientific Computation, Texas A&M University, College Station, TX, 1994.
J. M. Thomas, Sur l’analyse numerique des methodes d’elements finis hybrides et mixtes, Ph.D. Thesis, Université Pierre et Marie Curie, Paris, France, 1977.
Zhimin Zhang, Analysis of some quadrilateral nonconforming elements for incompressible elasticity, SIAM J. Numer. Anal., 34 (1997), 640–663

Information & Authors


Published In

cover image SIAM Journal on Numerical Analysis
SIAM Journal on Numerical Analysis
Pages: 2429 - 2451
ISSN (online): 1095-7170


Published online: 25 July 2006

MSC codes

  1. 65N30
  2. 41A10
  3. 41A25
  4. 41A27
  5. 41A63


  1. quadrilateral
  2. finite element
  3. approximation
  4. mixed finite element



Metrics & Citations



If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice. Simply select your manager software from the list below and click Download.

Cited By

View Options

View options


View PDF







Copy the content Link

Share with email

Email a colleague

Share on social media

The SIAM Publications Library now uses SIAM Single Sign-On for individuals. If you do not have existing SIAM credentials, create your SIAM account https://my.siam.org.